The Best Intentions

The Best Intentions

Unintended Pregnancy and the Well-Being of Children and Families

  • Author: Eisenberg, Leon; Brown, Sarah S.
  • Publisher: National Academies Press
  • ISBN: 9780309052306
  • eISBN Pdf: 9780309556378
  • eISBN Epub: 9780309176545
  • Place of publication:  United States
  • Year of digital publication: 1995
  • Month: June
  • Pages: 393
  • Language: English

Experts estimate that nearly 60 percent of all U.S. pregnancies—and 81 percent of pregnancies among adolescents—are unintended. Yet the topic of preventing these unintended pregnancies has long been treated gingerly because of personal sensitivities and public controversies, especially the angry debate over abortion. Additionally, child welfare advocates long have overlooked the connection between pregnancy planning and the improved well-being of families and communities that results when children are wanted.

Now, current issues—health care and welfare reform, and the new international focus on population—are drawing attention to the consequences of unintended pregnancy. In this climate The Best Intentions offers a timely exploration of family planning issues from a distinguished panel of experts.

This committee sheds much-needed light on the questions and controversies surrounding unintended pregnancy. The book offers specific recommendations to put the United States on par with other developed nations in terms of contraceptive attitudes and policies, and it considers the effectiveness of over 20 pregnancy prevention programs.

The Best Intentions explores problematic definitions—"unintended" versus "unwanted" versus "mistimed"—and presents data on pregnancy rates and trends. The book also summarizes the health and social consequences of unintended pregnancies, for both men and women, and for the children they bear.

Why does unintended pregnancy occur? In discussions of "reasons behind the rates," the book examines Americans' ambivalence about sexuality and the many other social, cultural, religious, and economic factors that affect our approach to contraception. The committee explores the complicated web of peer pressure, life aspirations, and notions of romance that shape an individual's decisions about sex, contraception, and pregnancy. And the book looks at such practical issues as the attitudes of doctors toward birth control and the place of contraception in both health insurance and "managed care."

The Best Intentions offers frank discussion, synthesis of data, and policy recommendations on one of today's most sensitive social topics. This book will be important to policymakers, health and social service personnel, foundation executives, opinion leaders, researchers, and concerned individuals.

  • The Best Intentions
  • Copyright
  • Acknowledgments
  • Contents
  • The Best Intentions
  • Summary
    • COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATIONS
      • The Campaign to Reduce Unintended Pregnancy
      • Campaign Leadership
  • 1 Introduction
    • FOCUS OF THIS REPORT
    • STUDY METHODS AND REPORT ORGANIZATION
  • 2 Demography of Unintended Pregnancy
    • TERMINOLOGY
    • PERCENTAGE RATES OF UNINTENDED PREGNANCY
    • WOMEN AT RISK OF UNINTENED PREGNANCY
    • WOMEN WHO HAVE UNINTENDED PREGNANCIES
    • TRENDS IN UNINTENDED PREGNANCY
      • Overall Trends for All Women
      • Trends Among Currently Married Women
      • Trends Among Never-Married Women
      • Trends in Births Unwanted at Conception
    • THE ROLE OF ABORTION
      • Factors That Affect Who Obtains an Abortion
    • INTERNATIONAL COMPARISONS
      • U.S. Abortion Rates Versus Other Western Democracies
    • CONCLUSION
    • REFERENCES
  • 3 Consequences of Unintended Pregnancy
    • ABORTION AS A CONSEQUENCE OF UNINTENDED PREGNANCY
      • Medical Complications
      • Rates of Complications
      • Psychological Issues
      • Political Issues
    • MATERNAL DEMOGRAPHIC STATUS
      • Adolescent Childbearing: Socioeconomic Issues
      • Adolescent Childbearing: Medical Issues
      • Childbearing at Older Ages: Socioeconomic and Medical Issues
      • Childbearing by Single Women
    • THE EFFECTS OF INTENDEDNESS
      • Methodological Concerns
      • Prenatal Care
      • Behavioral Risks in Pregnancy
      • Low Birthweight
      • Infant Mortality
      • Poor Child Health and Development
      • Consequences for the Parents
        • Mothers
        • Fathers
    • PRECONCEPTION CARE
    • THE DEMOGRAPHIC IMPLICATIONS OF REDUCING UNINTENDED PREGNANCY
    • CONCLUSION
    • REFERENCES
  • 4 Patterns of Contraceptive Use
    • PATTERNS OF CONTRACEPTIVE USE AND UNINTENDED PREGNANCY
      • Unintended Pregnancy Among Women Using No Contraception (Group C)
      • Unintended Pregnancy Among Women Using Contraception (Groups A and B)
        • Contraceptive Sterilization
        • Reversible Contraception
        • Current Choices Among Reversible Methods
        • Reversible Contraceptive Methods: Types and Trends
    • CONTRACEPTIVE USE AMONG MEN
      • Use of Male Methods of Contraception at First Intercourse
      • Use of Male Methods by Married Men
      • Age and Condom Use
      • Race, Ethnicity, and Condom Use
      • Socioeconomic Status and Condom Use
    • USE OF DUAL CONTRACEPTIVE METHODS
    • SEXUALLY TRANSMITTED DISEASES
    • CONCLUSION
    • REFERENCES
  • 5 Basic Requirements: Contraceptive Knowledge and Access
    • KNOWLEDGE, SKILLS, AND SCHOOL-BASED EDUCATION
      • Contraceptive Knowledge
      • Contraceptive Skills
      • School-Based Education and Information
    • ACCESS TO CONTRACEPTION
      • Data on Overall Access
      • Financial Barriers
        • Private Insurance
        • Health Maintenance Organizations
        • Public Sector Programs
        • Contraceptive Pricing
      • The Provider Base for Contraception
      • Bureaucratic Hurdles
    • MISSED OPPORTUNITIES
    • CONCLUSION
    • REFERENCES
  • 6 Personal and Interpersonal Determinants of Contraceptive Use
    • A COMMENT ON AVAILABLE DATA
    • UNDERLYING THEMES
    • SINGLE FACTOR INVESTIGATIONS
      • Personality Characteristics
      • Attitudes and Feelings About Sexuality and Fertility
      • Attitudes and Feelings About Contraceptive Methods
      • Substance Abuse, Peer Influences and Family Relationships
        • Alcohol and Substance Use
        • Parents and Peers
      • Partner and Couple Issues
    • CONCLUSION
    • REFERENCES
  • 7 Socioeconomic and Cultural Influences on Contraceptive Use
    • DIVERSITY IN U.S. CULTURE
      • Cultural and Ethnic Diversity
      • Religious and Political Diversity
    • CONFLICTING VIEWS ABOUT SEXUALITY
      • The Media
      • International Comparisons
    • ECONOMIC INFLUENCES ON FERTILITY
      • AFDC and Other Transfer Programs
        • Potential Influences
        • Empirical Findings
    • RACISM
      • Race, Welfare, and Birth Control
      • Genocide
    • VIOLENCE
    • GENDER BIAS
    • OPPOSITION TO ABORTION
    • CONCLUSION
    • REFERENCES
  • 8 Programs to Reduce Unintended Pregnancy
    • NATIONAL PROGRAMS
    • LOCAL PROGRAMS
      • Historical Perspective
      • Program Search and Selection
      • Evaluated Programs
      • A Comment on Program Evaluation
        • Cost
        • Methodological Issues
        • Social Environment
    • CROSS-CUTTING THEMES
    • THE FISCAL IMPACT OF FAMILY PLANNING FUNDING
      • Program Reactions to Funding Withdrawal
      • Treatment of Mistimed and Unwanted Pregnancies
      • Program Eligibility Versus Participation
      • Incomplete Accounting for Public Revenue Effects
    • CONCLUSION
    • REFERENCES10
  • 9 Conclusions and Recommendations
    • A NEW SOCIAL NORM
    • THE CAMPAIGN TO REDUCE UNINTENDED PREGNANCY
      • Campaign Goal 1: Improve knowledge about contraception, unintended pregnancy, and reproductive health.
        • Campaign Goal 2: Increase access to contraception.
        • • Campaign Goal 3: Explicitly address the major roles that feelings, attitudes, and motivation play ...
        • • Campaign Goal 4: Develop and scrupulously evaluate a variety of local programs to reduce unintende ...
        • • Campaign Goal 5: Stimulate research to (a) develop new contraceptive methods for both men and wome ...
    • CAMPAIGN LEADERSHIP
    • REFERENCES
  • Appendixes
    • A Commissioned and Contributed Papers
    • B The Political Storms over Family Planning: Supplement to Chapters 1 and 7
      • Historical Background
      • Conclusion
    • C The National Survey of Family Growth: Principal Source of Statistics on Unintended Pregnancy: Supplement to Chapter 2
      • Definitions and Measurement Issues
      • NSFG Plans for the Future
        • Improving Abortion Reporting
        • Clarifying Questions on Unwanted and Mistimed Pregnancies
        • Measuring Ambivalence about Pregnancy
        • Improving Questions on Unplanned Pregnancies and Use of Contraception
    • REFERENCES
    • D Tables of Odds Ratios: Supplement to Chapter 3
    • E Technical Notes on the Recalculation Exercise: Supplement to Chapter 3
      • Births Unwanted at Conception
      • Births Mistimed at Conception
    • F Summaries of Evaluated Programs: Supplement to Chapter 8
      • Community of Caring
        • Primary Reference:
      • Condom Mailing Program
        • Primary Reference:
      • Elmira Nurse Home Visiting Program
        • Primary References:
      • Facts and Feelings
        • Primary Reference:
      • Girls Incorporated Preventing Adolescent Pregnancy
        • Primary References:
      • Group Cognitive Behavior Curriculum
        • Primary References:
      • McCabe Center
        • Primary References:
      • New Chance
        • Primary References:
      • The Ounce of Prevention Fund's Parents Too Soon Program
        • Primary Reference:
      • Postponing Sexual Involvement
        • Primary References:
      • Project Redirection
        • Primary References:
      • Project Taking Charge
        • Primary References:
      • Reducing the Risk
        • Primary References:
      • Reproductive Health Screening of Male Adolescents
        • Primary References:
      • School/Community Program for Sexual Risk Reduction Among Teens
        • Primary References:
      • Self Center
        • Primary References:
      • Six School-Based Clinics
        • Primary Reference:
      • St. Paul School-Based Health Clinics
        • Primary References:
      • Success Express
        • Primary References:
      • Summer Training and Education Program
        • Primary Reference:
      • Teenage Parent Demonstration
        • Primary References:
      • Teen Outreach Program
        • Primary References:
      • Teen Talk
        • Primary References:
    • G Assessing Program Effectiveness and Cost-Effectiveness: Supplement to Chapter 8
      • Assessing Program Effectiveness
      • Assessing Cost-Effectiveness
        • Cost-Effectiveness in Family Planning
        • Dimensions of Cost-Effectiveness
        • Translating Service Statistics into Measures of Contraceptive Protection
        • Predicting Net Program Effects Without Individual Data
        • Estimating the Cost Functions
      • Summary
      • Conclusions
    • REFERENCES
  • Index

SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWSLETTER

By subscribing, you accept our Privacy Policy